Why Your Fleet's Fuel Economy May Be Slipping

The small losses that can quietly eat away at fuel economy in trucks

A man in blue pumps fuel into a white semi-truck at a fuel station.

Diesel prices hit new records in 2026, which means that even small fuel economy losses can be expensive. The challenge with small losses is that they can be hard to spot, but they add up over time. Missed maintenance, unnecessary idling, the wrong specs and other seemingly small issues can quietly drain fuel economy.


The Top Drains on Fuel Economy in Trucks

Today's engines are more efficient than ever, but they're also less forgiving. Many issues that decrease fuel efficiency don't set off an obvious warning, so they can go weeks unnoticed. Here are 9 potential fuel economy drains you should keep an eye on:

1. Settings that drift

Road speed and cruise speed settings are spec'd when a truck is ordered, but they don't always stay that way. Penske technicians sometimes find that someone has changed those settings after delivery. A truck allowed to run faster or idle longer burns more fuel on every shift. During preventive maintenance, Penske checks each truck's settings against how it was originally spec'd. On newer connected trucks, settings that have drifted can be corrected over the air.

2. Parts that fail in the "on" position

On late-model trucks, the engine fan engages only when the engine needs extra cooling, such as on a long climb. When a fan clutch, sensor or airline fails, the fan is designed to lock on so the engine doesn't overheat. That's the safe choice, but a fan that never shuts off draws considerable horsepower, and drivers often don't notice the difference.

Other problems hide in the engine's performance. There's no fault code for poor fuel economy, but connected trucks can flag related issues, such as emissions system faults or a turbocharger boost that's lower than it should be.

3. Friction you can't see

Small sources of friction can add up, too. An unlubricated fifth wheel takes more power to turn, and a tractor that isn't tracking straight with its trailer wears tires faster and wastes fuel. Tires can also be a common culprit of reduced fuel economy. Underinflated tires increase rolling resistance, for example. Aerodynamic devices need attention as well. Skirts and fairings sit low on the vehicle, where they're easily damaged, and a cracked or missing panel adds drag on every highway mile.

4. Unnecessary idling

Sleeper cabs get most of the attention when it comes to idling, but Penske often finds surprisingly high idle times on day cabs and straight trucks. Drivers keep the engine running to power the air conditioning or the liftgate. An idling truck burns fuel at zero miles per hour, pulling down its average MPG.

Auxiliary power units can help reduce the need to idle, but idle-reduction equipment needs maintenance, too. Auxiliary power units have filters, connections and other parts that need regular service. When that equipment doesn't work, drivers fall back on idling the engine.

5. Drains from the spec

A truck that isn’t spec’d for the right application [ML2] can use more fuel, and trucks spec'd perfectly for yesterday's operation can quietly cost fuel today. Routes shift, freight changes and customers move, but the equipment stays the same. Those types of shifts are happening across the industry.

The American Transportation Research Institute's (ATRI’s) 2026 Operational Costs of Trucking report found that local trips under 100 miles rose to 30% of all trips in 2025, up from 26% in 2024. National trips over 1,000 miles fell to 11%. A tractor spec'd for long highway runs, with the gearing and aerodynamics to match, may not be the most efficient choice for shorter regional work.

“The first step is understanding how a customer operates today compared with six years ago. Then we can recommend the optimal specification for where their operation is now,” said Paul Rosa, senior vice president of procurement and fleet planning for Penske Truck Leasing.

Weight also contributes to fuel efficiency. ATRI found that fleets with operating weights of 60,000 to 70,000 pounds averaged 7.56 mpg in 2025, while those above 80,000 pounds averaged 6.20 mpg. A fleet that fills its trailers by volume before reaching weight limits may need a different spec than one that regularly hauls at maximum weight.

6. Not every drain shows up on the truck itself

A well-maintained, properly spec'd tractor can still waste fuel if it runs empty, goes off route or gets detained at a dock. While those miles and hours don’t necessarily lower a truck's MPG, they burn fuel without moving freight.

7. Empty miles

Empty miles made up 16.5% of non-tank truckload miles in 2025, according to ATRI’s latest report. Truckload fleets with 251 to 1,000 trucks ran the most, at 18%. Finding backhauls can turn those return trips into productive miles, but finding the right backhauls can be a challenge.

ATRI noted that when freight volumes are low, fleets often focus on finding loads rather than optimizing their networks, and empty miles creep up. For private fleets, the primary focus is meeting their own service needs, so they only look for backhauls if they fit into their existing operational strategy and don’t negatively affect their drivers or operations.

8. Out-of-route miles

Every mile traveled outside of the most efficient route burns fuel and costs driver time. Out-of-route miles can come from poor stop sequencing, detours around congestion or outdated business rules that haven't been revisited, such as fixed early-morning delivery windows. Route optimization can help fleets find the most efficient paths while network optimization could create even more efficiency. Consolidating loads or moving to larger trailers could also reduce the number of trips needed.

9. Dwell time and detention

Time at the dock often means time idling. Average dwell time for dry vans rose to 1 hour and 49 minutes per stop, according to ATRI, just 11 minutes short of the two-hour threshold the industry uses to define detention. Plus, detention costs go beyond fuel. ATRI estimates detention cost truckload carriers $5,392 per truck. The latest report also found that every additional 30 minutes of average dwell time was associated with a 5.4-percentage-point increase in driver turnover.

Fleets can reduce dwell time by tracking it by customer and facility, working with shippers on appointment scheduling, and building detention into contracts.

How To Find What You Can't See

The hardest part of a quiet drain is knowing it's there. Fuel economy varies so widely by application, weight, region and duty cycle that a fleet's MPG means little on its own.

"Our customers want to know their utilization and miles-per-gallon not only for their vehicles but also across similar industries," said Samantha Thompson, vice president of customer success and fleet telematics for Penske Transportation Solutions. "I'm running a Class 8 and getting 5.8 miles per gallon. Is that good or bad?"

Industry averages offer only a rough answer. ATRI reported that for-hire tractors averaged 7.43 mpg in 2025, but that figure combines different operations. Penske created Comparative Insights powered by Catalyst AI™ to help fleets get true apples-to-apples comparisons of their fuel efficiency, utilization and maintenance performance with similar fleets.

Fleets can use their latest information to drill into individual vehicles and identify the trucks pulling the average down. They can also compare locations to see which hubs are underperforming. Comparative Insights also highlights the factors that most affect each fleet's performance, such as idle time. Those factors change over time, and once a fleet addresses one drain, a different one may rise to the top, which makes benchmarking an ongoing process rather than a one-time check.

Give Drivers Visibility

Drivers influence nearly every drain on this list, from idling to speed. Telematics data can show drivers how their habits compare and give managers specific behaviors to coach. Some fleets also reward results. ATRI found the average fuel economy bonus rose 25.3% to $1,548 in 2025, but only 12% of carriers offered one.

Benchmarking against fleets with similar operations gives a more useful comparison than an industry average. Fleets can try the free Fleet Benchmarking tool, powered by Catalyst AI, to see how they compare. Penske lease customers can access deeper insights through Fleet Insight™.

Common Questions

Fleet managers trying to track down decreasing fuel economy often have the same questions, so we've compiled our most frequently asked questions on fuel economy.

Why is my truck's fuel economy getting worse?

Common causes include speed or idle settings that have been changed, an engine fan stuck in the on position, underinflated tires, poor alignment and more idling. A truck can also lose fuel economy when the operation it runs in changes and its spec no longer fits. Comparing the truck with similar vehicles can help narrow down the cause.

Do empty miles hurt fuel economy?

Empty miles may not lower a truck's MPG, but they burn fuel without moving freight, which raises fuel cost per load. Empty miles made up 16.5% of non-tank truckload miles in 2025, according to ATRI.

How does detention affect fuel costs?

Trucks waiting at a dock often idle, burning fuel at zero miles per hour. Average dwell time reached 1 hour and 49 minutes per stop in 2025, according to ATRI, and refrigerated trucks averaged more than two and a half hours.

What is good fuel economy for a Class 8 truck?

It depends on the application, which is why broad industry averages may not tell the full story. ATRI reported that for-hire tractors averaged 7.43 mpg in 2025, but weight, route type, region and duty cycle all make a difference.